ERRussia 1917 – 1953
FILE NO. ER-01  ·  CLEARANCE: INVESTIGATOR

Russia1917 – 1953

Vladimir Lenin and the Bolsheviks, then Joseph Stalin

Click through every exhibit: use the arrows, your arrow keys, or swipe. Some photos show real death and hunger. Those are blurred until you tap them.

Exhibit A

Before

What was going wrong in Russia in 1917?

Exhibit A · Before
Petrograd, February 1917. Soldiers join the protests. It started when women in bread lines walked out. Within days the Tsar gave up his throne.

Petrograd, February 1917. Soldiers join the protests. It started when women in bread lines walked out. Within days the Tsar gave up his throne. Source: Wikimedia Commons

Tap the photo to zoom
Exhibit A · Before
~2,000,000
Russian soldiers killed in World War I
Estimates vary. Russia had been fighting since 1914, and food could not reach the cities.
Exhibit A · Before
Petrograd, July 4, 1917. People scatter after troops of the temporary government open fire on a street demonstration. The war, and the bread lines, went on.

Petrograd, July 4, 1917. People scatter after troops of the temporary government open fire on a street demonstration. The war, and the bread lines, went on. Source: Wikimedia Commons

Tap the photo to zoom
Exhibit B

The Promise

What did the Bolsheviks say they would give people? Copy their words.

Exhibit B · The Promise
Petrograd, 1917, between the two revolutions. Read the banners. The big one: <b>“All power to the Soviets of Workers’, Soldiers’ and Peasants’ Deputies.”</b> Above it: <b>“Long live an immediate ceasefire on all fronts.”</b> (A soviet was a council of elected workers and soldiers.)

Petrograd, 1917, between the two revolutions. Read the banners. The big one: “All power to the Soviets of Workers’, Soldiers’ and Peasants’ Deputies.” Above it: “Long live an immediate ceasefire on all fronts.” (A soviet was a council of elected workers and soldiers.) Source: Wikimedia Commons

Tap the photo to zoom
Exhibit B · The Promise
Peace, Land, and Bread!
Bolshevik slogan, 1917

Lenin promised an end to the war, farmland for peasants, food for the cities, and a government run by workers instead of the rich.

Exhibit B · The Promise

FILM Early Soviet newsreel of the revolution’s two leaders, Vladimir Lenin and Leon Trotsky. About 1½ minutes. Source: Wikimedia Commons

Exhibit B · The Promise
Moscow, May 5, 1920. Lenin speaks to Red Army soldiers leaving for the war with Poland. <b>Look closely at this photo. You will see it again.</b>

Moscow, May 5, 1920. Lenin speaks to Red Army soldiers leaving for the war with Poland. Look closely at this photo. You will see it again. Source: Wikimedia Commons

Tap the photo to zoom
Exhibit C

The Road to Power

Force, votes, or both? Find the turning point.

Exhibit C · The Road to Power
  1. NOV 7, 1917The Bolsheviks take over the capital in an armed uprising.
  2. DEC 20, 1917Lenin’s government creates a secret police, the Cheka.
Exhibit C · The Road to Power
24%
of the vote went to the Bolsheviks in Russia’s first free national election, November 1917
Another party won the most seats. In January 1918 the elected assembly met once. The Bolsheviks shut it down the next day and never let it meet again.
Exhibit C · The Road to Power
Hang (hang without fail, so the people see) no fewer than one hundred known kulaks, rich men, bloodsuckers.
Lenin, telegram to local officials in Penza, August 11, 1918
Exhibit C · The Road to Power
  1. 1918–1921Civil war. Opposition parties and newspapers are banned.
  2. 1924–1929Lenin dies. Joseph Stalin defeats his rivals inside the party and takes control.
  3. 1929–1933Peasants are forced onto state-run collective farms. Farmers who resist are labeled “kulaks” and shot or deported.
  4. 1937–1938The Great Terror. Party members, army officers, writers and ordinary people are arrested as “enemies of the people.”
Exhibit C · The Road to Power
Moscow, December 5, 1931. The government blows up the Cathedral of Christ the Saviour. (It was rebuilt in the 1990s.)

Moscow, December 5, 1931. The government blows up the Cathedral of Christ the Saviour. (It was rebuilt in the 1990s.) Source: Wikimedia Commons

Tap the photo to zoom
Exhibit C · The Road to Power
Moscow, December 1937. Stalin votes in the election for the Supreme Soviet. Every district had one approved candidate. Official result: 96.8% turnout, more than 99% for the Party’s list. On the far right: Nikolai Yezhov, head of the secret police during the arrests of 1937–38. He was shot in 1940.

Moscow, December 1937. Stalin votes in the election for the Supreme Soviet. Every district had one approved candidate. Official result: 96.8% turnout, more than 99% for the Party’s list. On the far right: Nikolai Yezhov, head of the secret police during the arrests of 1937–38. He was shot in 1940. Source: Wikimedia Commons

Tap the photo to zoom
Exhibit D

The Numbers

Did life get better or worse? Find the number that matters most to you.

Exhibit D · The Numbers
~3.9 million
deaths in the Ukrainian famine of 1932–33 (the Holodomor)
Demographers’ estimate. More died in Kazakhstan and Russia.
Exhibit D · The Numbers
~680,000
people shot in the Great Terror, 1937–38
Count from the secret police’s own records.
Exhibit D · The Numbers
~18 million
people passed through Gulag labor camps, 1930–1953
Historians’ estimate.
Exhibit D · The Numbers
Number of Gulag prisoners each year, 1934–1953, from Soviet records opened after 1991.

Number of Gulag prisoners each year, 1934–1953, from Soviet records opened after 1991. Source: Wikimedia Commons

Tap the photo to zoom
Exhibit D · The Numbers
5 years
in prison for taking a handful of grain from a collective farm field
As described by survivor Olexandra Rafalska; the 1932 “law of spikelets.”
Exhibit E

Witnesses

What did people who were there see? Pick one witness and follow the link.

Exhibit E · Witnesses
Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn
Source: Wikimedia Commons

Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn

Soviet army captain · arrested February 1945
The line dividing good and evil cuts through the heart of every human being.
Solzhenitsyn, The Gulag Archipelago

He was arrested because the censors read his private letters to a school friend, which criticized Stalin. He spent eight years in labor camps, then was sent into exile. His book The Gulag Archipelago (1973) collects the stories of hundreds of prisoners. In 1974 he was expelled from the Soviet Union.

Read his own account →
Exhibit E · Witnesses
Berliner Tageblatt, March 31, 1933: “Famine in Russia?”
Berliner Tageblatt, March 31, 1933: “Famine in Russia?” Source: Wikimedia Commons

Gareth Jones

Welsh journalist · walked through Ukrainian villages, March 1933

Jones slipped away from his official guides and walked from village to village. In Berlin he told reporters that everywhere he heard the same cry: “There is no bread. We are dying.” Two days later the New York Times Moscow correspondent, Walter Duranty, answered with a story headlined “Russians Hungry, But Not Starving.”

Read Jones’s report →
Exhibit E · Witnesses

Galina Gubenko

Survivor · village of Yaressky, Poltava region, Ukraine

More than half of her village died. Patrols searched homes and fields, took whatever food they found, and burned what they couldn’t carry. Her memory of the village: “There were no dogs and no cats.”

Read her account →
Exhibit E · Witnesses

Lev Kopelev

Soviet army officer · arrested 1945, sentenced to ten years

Kopelev was a loyal Communist, arrested for criticizing how Soviet soldiers treated German civilians. He describes a packed, sweltering cell, three days without bread, and a guard casually reporting that three prisoners had been shot that day.

See the Gulag exhibit →
Exhibit F

Propaganda vs. Evidence

Put what they showed next to what the camera caught. Where don’t they match?

Exhibit F · Propaganda vs. Evidence
Soviet poster, 1930: “We will drive the kulaks out of the collective farms.”

Soviet poster, 1930: “We will drive the kulaks out of the collective farms.” Source: Wikimedia Commons

Tap the photo to zoom
Exhibit F · Propaganda vs. Evidence
Life has become better, comrades; life has become more joyous.
Joseph Stalin, speech, November 1935
Exhibit F · Propaganda vs. Evidence
Kharkiv, Ukraine, 1933. Photographed secretly by Alexander Wienerberger, an Austrian engineer working in the USSR.
This photo shows people who have died of starvation in the street.Tap to view.

Kharkiv, Ukraine, 1933. Photographed secretly by Alexander Wienerberger, an Austrian engineer working in the USSR. Source: Wikimedia Commons

Tap the photo to zoom
Exhibit F · Propaganda vs. Evidence
Udachne, Donetsk region, 1933. Children dig for frozen potatoes left in a collective farm field.

Udachne, Donetsk region, 1933. Children dig for frozen potatoes left in a collective farm field. Source: Wikimedia Commons

Tap the photo to zoom
Exhibit F · Propaganda vs. Evidence

FILM A 1933 Soviet film celebrates the new White Sea Canal and shows the prisoners who built it being “remade” into honest workers. It runs 50 minutes: skim it. Source: Wikimedia Commons

Exhibit F · Propaganda vs. Evidence
1932. Prisoners dig the White Sea Canal, mostly by hand. More than 100,000 prisoners built it in under two years. Official records count about 12,000 deaths; some historians estimate 25,000.

1932. Prisoners dig the White Sea Canal, mostly by hand. More than 100,000 prisoners built it in under two years. Official records count about 12,000 deaths; some historians estimate 25,000. Source: Wikimedia Commons

Tap the photo to zoom
Exhibit F · Propaganda vs. Evidence
Look again. On the steps beside Lenin’s platform stand Leon Trotsky (in uniform) and Lev Kamenev. Soviet copies of this photo cut both men out. Kamenev was shot in 1936. Trotsky was murdered in Mexico in 1940 by a Soviet agent.Trotsky and Kamenev: removed

Look again. On the steps beside Lenin’s platform stand Leon Trotsky (in uniform) and Lev Kamenev. Soviet copies of this photo cut both men out. Kamenev was shot in 1936. Trotsky was murdered in Mexico in 1940 by a Soviet agent. Source: Wikimedia Commons

Exhibit G

The Complication

Which of these facts makes the regime harder to judge? Does it change your verdict?

Exhibit G · The Complication

FILM Moscow, March 9, 1953. Stalin’s funeral, filmed by Major Martin Manhoff, a U.S. army officer, from the American embassy balcony. Watch the crowds. About 10 minutes: skim it. Source: Wikimedia Commons

Exhibit G · The Complication

In the 1930s the Soviet Union built factories, dams and steel mills faster than almost any country in history.

Millions of peasants learned to read for the first time. By 1940 most young Soviets could read and write.

Exhibit G · The Complication
~27 million
Soviet lives lost in World War II
The Soviet army did most of the fighting that defeated Nazi Germany.
Exhibit G · The Complication

Your question: Does fast progress make up for the cost?

Who gets to decide that, and who paid?

Your investigation

Answer on your Evidence Log. Every answer needs evidence from this room: a date, a number, a quote, or a photo. Go back to any exhibit with the letters at the top.

  1. THE CRISIS. What was going wrong before they took power? Who was suffering?
  2. THE PROMISE. What did they promise? Copy their exact words.
  3. THE ROAD TO POWER. Did they get power by force, by votes, or both? Find the turning point.
  4. THE CRITICS. What happened to people who disagreed? Find a specific person or group.
  5. ORDINARY LIFE. Did life get better, worse, or both? Use a number.
  6. PROPAGANDA vs. EVIDENCE. Find one place where what they said and what happened don't match.
  7. THE COMPLICATION. What evidence makes this regime harder to judge?
All rooms →